Information Today, Inc. Corporate Site KMWorld CRM Media Streaming Media Faulkner Speech Technology Unisphere/DBTA
PRIVACY/COOKIES POLICY
Other ITI Websites
American Library Directory Boardwalk Empire Database Trends and Applications DestinationCRM EContentMag Faulkner Information Services Fulltext Sources Online InfoToday Europe KMWorld Library Resource Literary Market Place OnlineVideo.net Plexus Publishing Smart Customer Service Speech Technology Streaming Media Streaming Media Europe Streaming Media Producer Unisphere Research



For commercial reprints or PDFs contact Lauri Weiss-Rimler (lwrimler@infotoday.com)
Magazines > Online Searcher
Back Forward

ONLINE SEARCHER: Information Discovery, Technology, Strategies

Media Kit [PDF] Rate Card [PDF]
Editorial Calendar [PDF] Author Guidelines
SUBSCRIBE NOW! HOME

Sustainability of News and the Historical Record
By
Volume 45, Number 2 - March/April 2021

When I was growing up, my parents subscribed to the morning Pittsburgh Post-Gazette and the evening Pittsburgh Press. The Press ceased publishing in 1992, and, since 2018, the Post-Gazette prints only 3 days a week. If this chronology sounds familiar, it’s just a microcosm of the situation in other major cities. Local news is in peril; the sources are not sustainable.

What I didn’t know about as a child was the existence of another highly influential newspaper, the Pittsburgh Courier, now the New Pittsburgh Courier. It started in 1907 and was renamed in 1967 when new owners took over. It’s a weekly that covers the Black community in the city. Thanks to Newspapers.com, when I do a historical search on a Pittsburgh topic, I get the viewpoints from all three. A reminder: Language used in all three of these papers can be (and is) offensive by today’s standards. I was particularly taken aback by how people of Chinese descent were described in the Courier. Words used to describe the Black population of Pittsburgh reflect the times in both the Press and Post-Gazette. Not always pretty.

What is appropriate to include in newspaper stories has also changed drastically. It was once routine for reporters to check the local hotels’ guest registers and write stories about who was visiting their fair city. Thus, I learned that my great grandmother, with her three children, once visited New Orleans. I simply can’t imagine that type of story appearing in today’s newspapers, although I admit the historical record is fascinating and illuminating. But a sustainable reporting model? No.

Another sustainability issue: Formats are changing. If important essays are published on Medium and newsletters distributed via Substack, what does this mean for the sustainability of library collections? News isn’t the only type of information disappearing; it’s opinions that used to run in newspapers and in books that were essay collections.

What constitutes the historical record is shifting. Back when Pittsburgh had morning and evening newspapers, my parents thought they were well informed. They did not have to confront the myriad news sources, with varying degrees of reliability, that we have today. They did not confront clickbaity headlines or algorithmically determined stories. They never heard of social media. They fully understood, however, that multiple viewpoints existed and easily separated facts from opinions.

When newspaper preservation meant microfilm, we lost the context of color—microfilm is black and white—but gained the ability to read stories exactly as they were published. Digitized versions, however, can be altered. Stories can be removed. The Boston Globe initiative Fresh Start will update older articles about lesser crimes and misdemeanors or hide them from search engines. Other U.S. news outlets are following suit. In Europe, the General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR) legislates the right to be forgotten.

While much of this is laudable—some of these stories should probably never have been published—it opens a wider question: How will future researchers learn about today’s news? What do we decide is newsworthy and true? How do we ensure sustainability of news and the historical record?


Marydee Ojala is Editor-in-Chief of Online Searcher (the successor journal to ONLINE) and writes its business research column ("The Dollar Sign"). She contributes feature articles and news stories to Information TodayEContentComputers in LibrariesIntranetsCyberSkeptic's Guide to the InternetBusiness Information Review, and Information Today's NewsBreaks. A long-time observer of the information industry, she speaks frequently at conferences, such as WebSearch University, Internet Librarian, Online Information (London, UK), Internet Librarian International, and national library meetings outside the U.S. She has adjunct faculty status at the School of Library and Information Science at IUPUI (Indiana University Purdue University Indianapolis). Her professional career began at BankAmerica Corporation, San Francisco, directing a worldwide program of research and information services. She established her independent information research business in 1987. Her undergraduate degree is from Brown University and her MLS was earned at the University of Pittsburgh.

 

Comments? Email the editor-in-chief: marydee@xmission.com

       Back to top