Developments in Open Access, Search,
By Paula Hane
Following the busy conference period in June, many industry
companies seemed to take a breather from making big announcements during the
hot summer months, but things are bound to pick up soon. Many companies have
promised to announce big news during Q4 2004. And for opportunities to talk
to company representatives, see new products, and network with colleagues,
a roster of fall conferences will fill the bill. This month brings Outsell,
Inc.'s new conference (with the catchy name Go!) to Leesburg, Va., and Information
Today, Inc.'s WebSearch University returns to Washington, D.C. October will
feature Internet Librarian International in London and KMWorld & Intranets
in Santa Clara, Calif. November presents an opportunity to visit beautiful
Monterey, Calif., for the popular Internet Librarian conference.
It might have seemed quiet on one front, but there wereand continue
to beseveral busy spots for news. Open access continues to be a major
hot button for discussion, and developments with search engines and search
applications continue to be as active as ever.
As we go to press, Google, Inc. was opening the auction on its highly anticipated
$1.8 billion IPO. Maybe it was a Friday the 13th quirk, but early that day,
about a week before the auction opened, Google filed an amended document with
the SEC concerning comments made by its founders in the September 2004 issue
of Playboy. (What were they thinking?) There could be repercussions
if Google violated the "quiet period" securities rule. Things are never dull
when following news of this company.
On July 20, following 7 months of deliberation, the U.K. House of Commons'
Science and Technology Committee concluded that the current model for scientific
publishing is unsatisfactory and called on the U.K. government to support open
access (OA). In a NewsBreak, Information Today columnist Richard Poynder
reported on the publication of the committee's 118-page report ("Scientific
Publications: Free for All?"), which blamed the current situation on a "combination
of publishers' pricing [policies] and the inadequacy of library budgets" and
berated large commercial publishers like Reed Elsevier for clinging to an outdated
subscriber-pays publishing model in order to protect its "excessive profits."
Just before the U.K. report was published, the U.S. House of Representatives'
Committee on Appropriations recommended that the National Institutes of Health
provide free public access to research articles resulting from NIH-funded research
6 months after publication. The European Commission also is investigating the
STM publishing markets in Europe, so pressure is definitely mounting. The large
publishers are working to discredit the new author-pays models introduced by
OA publishers like BioMed Central and the Public Library of Science.
Then, BioMed Central announced that it would consult with librarians and
funding bodies about future mechanisms for funding open-access publishing.
The consultation workshop took place in London on Aug. 31. The publisher said
that conclusions of the meeting will be published this month.
Meanwhile, several scholarly research and library-related lists have absolutely
buzzed for months with questions, commentary, and debates on every conceivable
aspect of OA. This October, Internet Librarian International will feature an
Open Access Forum for Internet librarians. Richard Poynder (whose October Poynder
on Point column will focus on the history of OA) will interview the highly
opinionated and often-quoted Stevan Harnad, who can be observed debating the
subject of open access daily on his American Scientist Open Access Forum list,
which he has moderated since 1998. Then, a panel of experts will discuss the
challenges and opportunities for librarians, followed by an open discussion.
A similar forum will follow in November at Internet Librarian with a recap
of the London forum, including another interview with Harnad and further discussion.
The results of both will be published in Information Today and ONLINE.
Over the last several months we've seen a flurry of news from the search
engine companies. In addition to general search enhancements, the developments
focused on the following key areas: news, personalization, and local search
Microsoft has improved and streamlined its MSN search page, which still uses
results from Yahoo!, and has also made a trial version of its own in-development
search engine available on MSN's Sandbox site. The company, which obviously
has big plans to become a major search player, is said to be working on a desktop
search application as well.
MSN has been testing Newsbot, a personalized news service, in other countries
and has now gone live with a beta in the U.S. (in conjunction with MSNBC).
The personalized "virtual newsstand" on the MSNBC site taps over 4,800 sources
and includes coverage from the Associated Press. According to Barbara Quint,
users of the Newsbot service should notice one major difference from Google
News and even Yahoo! News. "The Newsbot service connects in every category
to related reference tools. It integrates content from searches and news feeds
with sources available on the portal," she wrote.
MSN also has acquired Lookout Software, makers of a personal Microsoft Outlook
2003 search tool. Lookout enables fast search on a user's PC for e-mail, files,
Outlook data such as calendar entries, and desktop searches. Desktop search
applications are definitely a hot area to watch.
Yahoo! has been busy as well, tweaking its service and adding content. In
a recent NewsBreak, Quint reported on Yahoo!'s successful addition of the OCLC
Open WorldCat content through Yahoo!'s Content Acquisition Program. In the
article, David Mandelbrot, Yahoo!'s vice president of search content, talked
about the company's plans. "Down the road we are focused on personalized search.
We have a team of engineers working on discovering user intentions when they
do a search. We're looking at folders and clustering and other personalization
techniques. Relevancy and freshness are huge priorities for us, and our technology
does a much better job in those areas as well as in comprehensiveness."
Yahoo! also launched a redesign of its search engine results page with an "also
try" link providing suggested search query terms, again focusing on closing
in on searcher intentions. And InfoWorld reported that Yahoo! is working
on a desktop search application: "In addition to letting users search their
local mail and hard drive, Yahoo's tool will extend the search to include personal
files stored at its online services, such as e-mail, calendar, and picture
The general Web search engines are not the only ones offering personalization
features. Endeca announced the availability of Endeca ProFind 4.5, a new version
of the company's enterprise search and navigation platform. The new features
are designed to improve relevancy, customize the discovery process, and further
simplify administration and management. The platform also offers personalized
content-spotlighting. Based on a user's known job function, geography, preferences,
history, etc., it will dynamically display specific content related to a search
query or browse path.
Local Search Is Hot
Ask Jeeves, Inc. has licensed Citysearch's local content, business data,
and user ratings to help power Smart Search results for local searches on Ask
Jeeves. The Smart Search technology provides direct links or a direct answer
at the top of the results page.
Yahoo!, Inc. released a beta of Yahoo! Local that integrates proprietary
Yahoo! Search Technology, Yellow Pages (with more than 14 million businesses)
and maps offerings, and third-party and user-generated content to create an
improved local search experience for consumers. A number of personalization
features are part of the package.
China Daily Information Co., in a partnership with China Communications Corp.,
is getting ready to launch "a new revolutionary business search engine, utilizing
a new and proprietary artificial intelligence technology." In a July press
announcement, the companies said they would launch the portal Acoona this December
in the U.S. and China, which, they state, will deliver "the most relevant business
search engine results." According to the press release, the technology uses
a complex algorithm that recalculates the meaning of words to better understand
the user's search query. "Acoona's Artificial Intelligence Technology will
elevate search engine performance to a new, unprecedented level," said Eckhard
Pfeiffer, former CEO of COMPAQ Computer and chairman of China Communications
Corp.'s board of consultants. According to information on the site, Acoona
will feature extensive business dataon a reported 50 million companies
worldwidepreviously not available on the Internet. We'll be watching
for this one.
FIND/SVP and two partners introduced a new business search engine, Find.com.
The free search aggregates results from major Web search engines and 3,000
selected business Web sites. Also provided is access to an eclectic group of
premium research content that can be purchased on a per-document basis. The
initial group of content providers included The Gallup Organization, Frost & Sullivan,
BNET, ChoicePoint, NetContent, and FIND/SVP. Also available are AdForum.com
and data from Devonshire Associates, Ltd., a provider of marketing information
products and services.
More on Desktop Search
This summer, blinx, a new Web and desktop search tool, was launched. The
free, downloadable application claims to use self-learning algorithms to understand
the context of what you are reading on your computer screen, such as documents,
e-mails, Web sites, news articles, blogs, and even videos. While it has received
a great deal of positive press coverage, my initial testing gave me inadequate
relevance and usefulness. But this is a product to watch as it develops.
X1 Technologies, Inc. updated its desktop search application with enhanced
query capabilities and broader support of file attachments. X1 first launched
its X1 Search application in February as a way for users to quickly find e-mails,
attachments, contacts, and desktop files. X1's file-filter technology lets
users preview and index the contents of 255 files in their native formats,
whether or not the native applications are installed.
Traditional Services' Upgrades
This seems to be the year for the traditional services to work on major upgrades
to their technology platforms and interfaces. In July, ProQuest rolled out
the latest release of its online service. It introduced ProQuest Smart Search,
a technology that taps ProQuest's indexing to offer suggestions to users. The
new service also provides advanced browsing, enhanced linking, and enhanced
The following is a brief roundup of other upgrades:
Ovid is now finishing up the architectural work on its platform,
which will allow it to be more nimble in the marketplace and introduce
Dialog introduced a new platform and enhanced interfaces to
both Dialog Profound and Dialog NewsRoom. The company continues to work on
Early this fall, Ingenta, Inc. will replace its two existing
online research interfaces (Ingenta and Ingentaselect) with IngentaConnect.
The newly architected platform allows Ingenta to provide simplified navigation,
improved linking, and enhanced personalization.
Thomson Gale currently is working on a significant adjustment
to its data architecture and a major technological initiative to create
one fully searchable platform for
all its content.
While the general Web search engines are busy adding more advanced features
and reaching out to add hidden Web and scholarly content, the traditional services
are working hard to upgrade their technologies and improve the user experience,
making it easier to get to the right information faster and in a more streamlined,
point-and-click environment. It will be interesting to watch as the two sides
move closer together.
Miscellaneous Content News
On Oct. 1, ERIC will introduce free-of-charge, full-text non-journal ERIC
resources. These materials include more than 105,000 full-text documents authorized
for electronic ERIC distribution from 1993 to July 2004, previously sold through
E*Subscribe from the ERIC Document Reproduction Service (EDRS). EDRS,
which also sells the ERIC microfiche, is scheduled to shut down operations
on Sept. 30.
An international agreement will expand the backfiles of historically significant
medical journals and make them freely available via PubMed Central. The Wellcome
Trust, in partnership with the Joint Information Systems Committee, and the
U.S. National Library of Medicine are joining forces to digitize the complete
backfiles of a number of titles. NLM is managing and hosting the archive.
For the latest industry news, check https://www.infotoday.com every Monday
morning. An easier option is to sign up for our free weekly e-mail newsletter,
NewsLink, which provides abstracts and links to the stories we post.
Paula J. Hane is Information Today, Inc.'s news bureau chief
and editor of NewsBreaks. Her e-mail address is firstname.lastname@example.org.